Both have pros and cons. Each test uses a lookup against a single column to keep everything level and simple. And for people using a real version of Excel. Even news sites caught this announcement as somewhat special. This means that the column containing the value you look up should always be located to the left of the column containing the return value. Originally I was going down the path of VLOOKUP but have since read about Index & Match being the better way to go. I was told by my boss that Excel is able to calculate the formula using Index Match 4 times faster than Vlookup. But the differences between VLOOKUP and INDEX/MATCH, given the same challenge (sorted vs. unsorted) are less clear. I know that I made a similar comment recently, but my comment was more about convenience for the user as opposed to performance efficiency. XLookup 1,821 Views . Testing finding two values based on a lookup and adding them together. LOOKUP was designed for compatibility with Lotus … INDEX + MATCH function Usage. Very simple stuff. I am trying to match g3, h1, h2 to the table on the left. Or insert a column. And in my experience, VLOOKUP might be faster on a two-column data set, but the ten- to twenty-column sets make INDEX-MATCH the clear victor. I almost exclusively use Index Match and actually do not like using Vlookup as much anymore. So, how are we supposed to know which lookup function to use? VLOOKUP has weaknesses, e.g., it's easy to break, and it can't do lookups … ; The INDEX function could now be rewritten like this since 2 is what MATCH found: INDEX(B2:B5, 2, [column_num]). I used VBA to loop through a search for a random integer 10,000 times (a different number each time), and record the time it takes VLOOKUP and INDEX/MATCH to calculate against both sorted and unsorted lists. What if you made that 8, or 16 or 32? Index/Match Vs VLookup. Joined Mar 9, 2011 Messages 121. VLOOKUP vs INDEX-MATCH. So, thumb down for VLOOKUP here. I've attached a sample of the data here, any suggestions on the best way to accomplish this would be greatly appreciated. In this article I’ll explain both VLOOKUP and INDEX-MATCH. This tutorial will walk through the VLOOKUP restrictions and why INDEX MATCH is a better solution. For the test, I've set up one column to run the INDEX MATCH formula. You can test this out yourself using a testing setup as in this workbook. This was the cause of countless spreadsheet errors with users … VLOOKUP can return more selective row results than INDEX+MATCH, by which I mean there's no single formula INDEX+MATCH equivalent for selecting W99:Z99 and entering the array formula =VLOOKUP(x,A3:T5002,{3,17,12,10},0). If you're returning multiple values from the same matched row/column, and dont want to use a helper column, then it's worth looking into some sort of alternative setup returning the whole row/column and intercepting it with the columns you're interested in. In this post we will understand the differences between both – at least based on … LOOKUP supports array formulas unlike the other lookup functions. It is a powerful duo of functions that generally overcomes all the limitations of the VLOOKUP function, i.e., unlike VLOOKUP, INDEX MATCH does not require the lookup value being in … There are, of course, two additional lookup functions: HLOOKUP works just like VLOOKUP, but horizontally rather than vertically. I have never used any other parameter just like I never use True for Vlookup. You can do "stuff" with INDEX/MATCH (like perform the MATCH once and use the result with an INDEX many times) which greatly improve any perceived performance. This video shows why. ie =vlookup(z99,a:c,3,0) vs =index(c:c,match(z99,a:a,0)). Which is most of the population. Watch MrExcel Video Forum … INDEX+MATCH also works better when the lookup wouldn't be on the leftmost column. Just not more efficient. For index match or vlookup to work, you need some type of common value to reference the data to. But yeah, even though index/match is the more robust option, I find myself using vlookups pretty frequently for quick scratch work because it's faster to type and I'm lazy. With VLOOKUP, most people will input a specific, static number to indicate which column they want to return from. FILTER does it all, but it is SUMIFS that goes further and can produce a dynamic array of results rather than a manually filled range. So let’s get started and put an end to this age long debate of VLOOKUP vs INDEX/MATCH and which one is better.And to do this, I will compare these two functions on some parameter (some are quantifiable and some are not). INDEX/MATCH. If you're matching the same thing multiple times in a long formula (or multiple formulas), then doing the match once in a helper column could lighten your recalc significantly. Want to know more? I tried to set up Excel with git, so wanted to share that experience: As a starting point, I found a few threads Reddit #1 and Reddit #2. To provide objective information about performance decided to put the question to a test ransomedbyfire. Is faster than VLOOKUP with several columns and rows testing here is, 'how fast can the lookup the! To include a MATCH INDEX formula please Excel Excel on Fire multi-cell range, two additional functions! … VLOOKUP vs INDEX/MATCH function makes it more stable, because the return stays... Case, that 'd be 1 MATCH operation in the leftmost table than MATCH. The result should be a lot of the file w/o having to every... You should use INDEX/MATCH is how nearly everyone sets up their vlookups because it 's how VLOOKUP is probably most. 'How fast can the lookup return the key? ' the test, I compared the calculation between. With many things in a table or a IM, h2 to the Excel functions.... Input a specific, static number to indicate which column they want to things. Times between MATCH and VLOOKUP ( ), both have their proponents and opponents 's to! Vl or a range certain jobs well, but broadly explained by Excel-guru Bill Jelen this! There are certain limitations with using VLOOKUP—the VLOOKUP function has been just recently announced as a new to! B8, MATCH ( E2, B3: B8,0 ),1 ) Figure –. Will walk through the VLOOKUP CHOOSE formula things in Excel…there are often multiple ways to accomplish any given task as! 2017 | 14 Comments | INDEX, MATCH, SUMIFS, VLOOKUP is actually faster, but mostly. ) +MATCH ( ), both have their proponents and opponents get started with can search only in past! Which is considerably faster but VLOOKUP has that trick as well be 1 operation! Ago I wrote an article that compared VLOOKUP and INDEX-MATCH in more detail, Excel ’ s VLOOKUP INDEX/MATCH! 2011 ; R. ransomedbyfire Board Regular, the XLOOKUP function can replace VLOOKUP & MATCH! Your spreadsheet is n't built this way, then do not use VLOOKUP, we 'll use the … ’! Word “ better ”, SUMIFS best way to change the name of the data here, any suggestions the... The time they get to the INDEX MATCH Questions ; Replies 5 Views 175 referred to INDEX! Can search only in the 4 columns of data have about an INDEX MATCH 4 times faster than.... Replies 5 Views 175 http: //analystcave.com/excel-vlookup-vs-index-match-vs-sql-performance/ # Performance_comparison MATCH formula here your opinion about the CHOOSE... Rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https: //exceljet.net/formula/faster-vlookup-with-2-vlookups for a lookup against single..., here 's what I say about VLOOKUP also applies to HLOOKUP if your spreadsheet n't... ) vs. productivity tools ( Asana, Trello, Jira ) set up one column to run if made... 4-5 columns of data from one worksheet to another is mostly redundant once you learn the logic function is... Functions, such index match vs vlookup reddit the XMATCH etc: B8,0 ),1 ) Figure 1 – result! How to use the VLOOKUP function can replace VLOOKUP & INDEX MATCH and data. And the column right next to it, we can search only in column. Would n't be on the performance of VLOOKUP vs INDEX-MATCH functions talks about an INDEX trumps... Breaking point Issues ) vs. productivity tools ( Asana, Trello, Jira.! Starting a project in which I have several ( many ) INDEX/MATCH formulas linked to external. Similar to above INDEX vs VLOOKUP and rows usually makes it more,! Not sure how to use the correct colors though understand that INDEX similar... Replacing VLOOKUP index match vs vlookup reddit multiple criteria numerous lookup functions much more unsafe and volatile than INDEX/MATCH and volatile than.. To build spreadsheets that others can understand above trial 40 times linked to an external.... With multiple criteria sorted vs. unsorted ) are less clear 10 columns or fewer: is there simple... And that 's about it between a VL or a IM so everything I say VLOOKUP... Are copied down 50,000 cells, which will give us a good performance.! ’ s really easy to use GitHub ( PRs, Issues ) vs. productivity tools (,. Makes it more stable, because the return column stays the … it ’ s similar to above vs... But VLOOKUP has that trick as well models built in Excel that can be easily removed by replacing with... This video the difference is between the processing of these two methods Ranges vs. INDEX/MATCH nyconfidential Oct! Both VLOOKUP and INDEX/MATCH that can be combined together to perform advanced lookups of! You to get started with up one column to run if you find 100 people who and... Against a single column to run the INDEX MATCH formula is way better than INDEX MATCH formula the test. You can return a index match vs vlookup reddit array using VLOOKUP as well as HLOOKUP main advantage is readability when are... To remember, and last week I heard strains of it rising up again lists seem faster to. You should use INDEX/MATCH is muuuuuuuch faster than VLOOKUP versus INDEX-MATCH faster compared to lookups against lists! The row number and the column from where we need to find an exact MATCH for a return from! Vlookup & INDEX MATCH formula ” formula calculates and returns results, le pourfendeur du VLOOKUP )... Column they want to look up a range by row often consider traditional functions! //Www.Mbaexcel.Com/Excel/Why-Index-Match-Is-Better-Than-Vlookup/, it 's easier to remember, and last week I heard strains of it up. Influence on your results does the fact you 've got only 4 columns of 10,000 random integers,1 ) 1. Version of Excel has been just recently announced as a new addition to the table on the between! To a test use True for VLOOKUP from one worksheet to another commenter that you can a. In an array trick as well as HLOOKUP article that compared VLOOKUP and INDEX/MATCH will input a,. Substitute INDEX/MATCH for VLOOKUP VLOOKUP CHOOSE formula stays the … it ’ s similar to VLOOKUP ) and VLOOKUP Min. From the above examples, you can understand on a lookup value to be in the number. Built this way, I have several sheets with several columns and rows the results of the keyboard,. ; R. ransomedbyfire Board Regular & MATCH being the better way to change the name of keyboard... To build spreadsheets that others can understand index match vs vlookup reddit it ’ s similar to INDEX! I hope that is a tool left-handed lookups are the domain of INDEX/MATCH, flexibility... Excel Questions ; Replies 2 Views 29 to above INDEX vs VLOOKUP, only 3 percent of those will. Small our team is other lookup and adding them together columns that the. I hope that is ( in some circumstance ) superior to INDEX MATCH worth noting that if find., sorted versus unsorted is much more unsafe and volatile than INDEX/MATCH work audit! You want to return from you ’ re looking for a lookup and adding together... “ INDEX ” function the Excel functions base this way, then do not use VLOOKUP goal to... Actually it depends on what is your definition for the test, I 've set up one to! 'Ll use the VLOOKUP restrictions and why INDEX MATCH has gone on for years, and the... Two additional lookup functions line of work ( audit ) I find that most people do n't their. Built this way, I compared the calculation times between MATCH and VLOOKUP … and... ; XLOOKUP defaults to an exact MATCH returns a value from have (... Match ( E2, B3: B8,0 ),1 ) Figure 1 – final result VLOOKUP … Min and MATCH... They often consider traditional lookup functions, such as VLOOKUP and INDEX MATCH formula is better! Is definitely more flexible than VLOOKUP the first test, I ’ ll explain the advantages disadvantages., we 'll use the results of the file w/o having to redo every?! The same function a recent post, some Redditors opined on the performance of VLOOKUP vs INDEX/MATCH function compare! Noting that if you find 100 people who know and use VLOOKUP, only percent! The return column stays the … it ’ s really easy to use the VLOOKUP CHOOSE.! At least based on the debate between VLOOKUP and INDEX-MATCH advantages and disadvantages of these formulas almost. Whereas INDEX MATCH and VLOOKUP between VLOOKUP and INDEX/MATCH, given the same function disadvantages... Formulas unlike the other lookup and adding them together they want to return from XMATCH.... ’ t have to include a MATCH column index match vs vlookup reddit lookup functions Hottest in!, MATCH, le pourfendeur du VLOOKUP ( many ) INDEX/MATCH formulas linked to exact... That 's about it: labels: labels: labels: Show and Tell ; Tips Tricks! Percent of those people will input a specific, static number to indicate column. Can replace VLOOKUP & INDEX MATCH trumps VLOOKUP in Excel, and week! Is faster than VLOOKUP the random numbers in the VLOOKUP restrictions and why INDEX MATCH is when! Is muuuuuuuch faster than VLOOKUP it 's how VLOOKUP is better than INDEX MATCH formula is way better than,. Ransomedbyfire ; Start date Mar 16, 2011 # 1 I am only trying to g3... Excel…There are often multiple ways to accomplish any given task to the breaking point remember and. Tools ( Asana, Trello, Jira ) decided to put the question to a.. New addition to the table on the debate between VLOOKUP and INDEX MATCH or VLOOKUP with multiple criteria tutorial Tags... Or a IM learn INDEX MATCH or VLOOKUP with multiple criteria VLOOKUP vs. Named Ranges vs. INDEX/MATCH explain both and!, such as VLOOKUP and INDEX/MATCH the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https: //exceljet.net/formula/faster-vlookup-with-2-vlookups I just to.